Switch from `toml` to `toml_edit` crate for incremental TOML editing,
preserving user-written comments, whitespace, and key ordering in
Codex config.toml.
Changes:
- Add toml_edit 0.22 dependency for preserving-style TOML editing
- Refactor sync_enabled_to_codex() to use toml_edit::DocumentMut API
- Implement smart style detection: inherit existing mcp.servers or
mcp_servers style, with fallback to sensible defaults
- Add deduplication logic to prevent both styles coexisting
- Add tests for format preservation and style inheritance
- Fix unused_mut and nonminimal_bool compiler warnings
- Apply cargo fmt to all modified files
Benefits:
- User comments and formatting are no longer lost during sync
- Respects user's preferred TOML structure (nested vs toplevel)
- Non-MCP fields in config.toml remain untouched
- Minimal surprise principle: only modifies necessary sections
Testing:
- All 47 tests passing (unit + integration)
- Clippy clean (0 warnings, 0 errors)
- Release build successful
- New tests verify comment preservation and style detection
This commit continues the backend refactoring initiative by extracting
configuration management and API speedtest logic into dedicated service
layers, completing phase 4 of the architectural improvement plan.
## Changes
### New Service Layers
- **ConfigService** (`services/config.rs`): Consolidates all config
import/export, backup management, and live sync operations
- `create_backup()`: Creates timestamped backups with auto-cleanup
- `export_config_to_path()`: Exports config to specified path
- `load_config_for_import()`: Loads and validates imported config
- `import_config_from_path()`: Full import with state update
- `sync_current_providers_to_live()`: Syncs current providers to live files
- Private helpers for Claude/Codex-specific sync logic
- **SpeedtestService** (`services/speedtest.rs`): Encapsulates endpoint
latency testing with proper validation and error handling
- `test_endpoints()`: Tests multiple URLs concurrently
- URL validation now unified in service layer
- Includes 3 unit tests for edge cases (empty list, invalid URLs, timeout clamping)
### Command Layer Refactoring
- Move all import/export commands to `commands/import_export.rs`
- Commands become thin wrappers: parse params → call service → return JSON
- Maintain `spawn_blocking` for I/O operations (phase 5 optimization)
- Lock acquisition happens after I/O completes (minimize contention)
### File Organization
- Delete: `import_export.rs`, `speedtest.rs` (root-level modules)
- Create: `commands/import_export.rs`, `services/config.rs`, `services/speedtest.rs`
- Update: Module declarations in `lib.rs`, `commands/mod.rs`, `services/mod.rs`
### Test Updates
- Update 20 integration tests in `import_export_sync.rs` to use `ConfigService` APIs
- All existing test cases pass without modification to test logic
- Add 3 new unit tests for `SpeedtestService`:
- `sanitize_timeout_clamps_values`: Boundary value testing
- `test_endpoints_handles_empty_list`: Empty input handling
- `test_endpoints_reports_invalid_url`: Invalid URL error reporting
## Benefits
1. **Improved Testability**: Service methods are `pub fn`, easily callable
from tests without Tauri runtime
2. **Better Separation of Concerns**: Business logic isolated from
command/transport layer
3. **Enhanced Maintainability**: Related operations grouped in cohesive
service structs
4. **Consistent Error Handling**: Services return `Result<T, AppError>`,
commands convert to `Result<T, String>`
5. **Performance**: I/O operations run in `spawn_blocking`, locks released
before file operations
## Testing
- ✅ All 43 tests passing (7 unit + 36 integration)
- ✅ `cargo fmt --check` passes
- ✅ `cargo clippy -- -D warnings` passes (zero warnings)
## Documentation
Updated `BACKEND_REFACTOR_PLAN.md` to reflect completion of config and
speedtest service extraction, marking phase 4 substantially complete.
Co-authored-by: Claude Code <code@anthropic.com>
Replace Mutex with RwLock for AppState.config to enable concurrent reads,
improving performance for tray menu building and query operations that
previously blocked each other unnecessarily.
Key changes:
- Migrate AppState.config from Mutex<MultiAppConfig> to RwLock<MultiAppConfig>
- Distinguish read-only operations (read()) from mutations (write()) across
all command handlers and service layers
- Offload blocking file I/O in import/export commands to spawn_blocking threads,
minimizing lock hold time and preventing main thread blocking
- Extract load_config_for_import() to separate I/O logic from state updates
- Update all integration tests to use RwLock semantics
Performance impact:
- Concurrent reads: Multiple threads can now query config simultaneously
(tray menu, provider list, MCP config)
- Reduced contention: Write locks only acquired during actual mutations
- Non-blocking I/O: Config import/export no longer freezes UI thread
All existing tests pass with new locking semantics.
- Extract internal functions in commands/mcp.rs and commands/provider.rs
to enable unit testing without Tauri context
- Add test hooks: set_mcp_enabled_test_hook, import_mcp_from_claude_test_hook,
import_mcp_from_codex_test_hook, import_default_config_test_hook
- Migrate error types from String to AppError for precise error matching in tests
- Extend ProviderService with delete() method to unify Codex/Claude cleanup logic
- Add comprehensive test coverage:
- tests/mcp_commands.rs: command-level tests for MCP operations
- tests/provider_service.rs: service-level tests for switch/delete operations
- Run cargo fmt to fix formatting issues (EOF newlines)
- Update BACKEND_REFACTOR_PLAN.md to mark phase 3 complete
Architecture improvements:
- Extract ProviderService with switch/backfill/write methods
- Reduce command layer from 160 to 13 lines via delegation
- Separate business logic (services) from state management (commands)
- Introduce precise error handling with structured validation
Refactoring details:
- Split Codex/Claude switching into symmetric private methods
- Add multi-layer validation for Codex auth field (existence + type)
- Extract import_config_from_path for command and test reuse
- Expose export_config_to_file and ProviderService in public API
Test coverage:
- Add 10+ integration tests for Claude/Codex switching flows
- Cover import/export success and failure scenarios (JSON parse, missing file)
- Verify state consistency on error paths (current remains unchanged)
- Test snapshot backfill for both old and new providers after switching
Key improvements:
- Extract switch_provider_internal() returning AppError for better testability
- Fix backup mtime inheritance: use read+write instead of fs::copy to ensure latest backup survives cleanup
- Add 15+ integration tests covering provider commands, atomic writes, and rollback scenarios
- Expose write_codex_live_atomic, AppState, and test hooks in public API
- Extract tests/support.rs with isolated HOME and mutex utilities
Test coverage:
- Provider switching with live config backfill and MCP sync
- Codex atomic write success and failure rollback
- Backup retention policy with proper mtime ordering
- Negative cases: missing auth field, invalid provider ID
Expand test suite from 3 to 11 integration tests, adding comprehensive coverage
for Codex dual-file atomicity and bidirectional MCP synchronization:
New Codex sync tests:
- sync_codex_provider_writes_auth_and_config: validates atomic write of auth.json
and config.toml, plus SSOT backfill of latest toml content
- sync_enabled_to_codex_writes_enabled_servers: MCP projection to config.toml
- sync_enabled_to_codex_removes_servers_when_none_enabled: cleanup when all disabled
- sync_enabled_to_codex_returns_error_on_invalid_toml: error handling for malformed TOML
New Codex MCP import tests:
- import_from_codex_adds_servers_from_mcp_servers_table: imports new servers from live config
- import_from_codex_merges_into_existing_entries: smart merge preserving SSOT server configs
New Claude MCP tests:
- sync_claude_enabled_mcp_projects_to_user_config: enabled/disabled filtering for .claude.json
- import_from_claude_merges_into_config: intelligent merge preserving existing configurations
Expand lib.rs API exports:
- Codex paths: get_codex_auth_path, get_codex_config_path
- Claude MCP: get_claude_mcp_path
- MCP sync: sync_enabled_to_claude, sync_enabled_to_codex
- MCP import: import_from_claude, import_from_codex
- Error type: AppError (for test assertions)
Test infrastructure improvements:
- Enhanced reset_test_fs() to clean .claude.json
- All tests use isolated HOME directory with sequential execution via mutex
Test results: 11/11 passed
Files changed: 3 (+394/-6 lines)
Next steps: Command layer integration tests and error recovery scenarios
